England Penalty Shoot Outs
- The first penalty shoot-out, or to give it it's official name "Kicks from the penalty mark", that England were involved in, was against Germany in the World Cup '90 semi-final.
Penalty shoot-outs are not covered in the rules of the game as dictated by the rule making body IFAB. They are primarily used in competitions where a result must be forced on the day. The first major tournament to include penalty shoot-outs was the 1976 European Championship. Prior to that there was usually a replay within a couple of days of the draw, or in the case of the Home Championship the title was shared, but in today's modern game it would be impossible to countenance that. Shoot-outs are used only to decide which team progresses in a tournament. They are not used to decide which team wins. "Won on penalties" is a misnomer, it is technically "Progressed on penalties" and the game is classified as a draw.
- Why do England always do badly in Penalty Shoot-Outs? - a bit of englandstats analysis - November 2018.
England traditionally have been awful at Penalty Shoot-Outs. Until the 2018 World Cup finals they had only triumphed in one - against Spain in Euro '96, however they successfully doubled their tally when they overcame Colombia in the last 16 at the 2018 World Cup. Won 2 Lost 7. Work in progress, I guess?!
The number of penalties taken is relatively even: England 45 - Opposition 46. So we can have a look at the numbers to see if a pattern emerges. Hitting the target doesn't seem to be a problem. England have only missed the target three times whilst opposition takers have missed six times. So clearly being able to hit a target 24ft wide and 8ft high from 12 yards is not the issue. However, if we look at the goalkeepers we find that opposition 'keepers managed to save 12 England penalties whereas England goalkeepers have only saved four. Also, in all but one of the penalty shoot-outs the opposition goalkeeper has managed to save at least one of England's spot kicks.
Being able to tuck the ball just inside the post or into the roof of the net is difficult and the risk of missing the target obviously increases. What we can read from the statistics is that English takers seem to be more content with the 50/50 approach of trying to make the 'keeper dive the wrong way, whereas opposition takers are far more willing to take a risk of putting the ball beyond the reach of the 'keeper. It's only a small data sample but it would seem that it's a risk worth taking.
- June 2019 Update
England have since gone on to win another shoot-out, this time against Switzerland in the UEFA Nations League in June 2019. So we now have a larger data sample than before. Both recent shoot-outs (2018 & 2019) have expanded on the theory that England players have no problem hitting the target. They have successfully converted 10 out of their last 11 penalties.
England Penalty Shoot Out Takers
- Player
- Total
- Scored
- Missed
- Conv %
England Penalty Shoot Outs by Competition
- Type
- Total
- Scored
- Missed
- Conversion %
- World Cup Finals
- 19
- 11
- 8
- 57.9%
- European Championship Finals
- 21
- 16
- 5
- 76.2%
- King Hassan II Tournament
- 5
- 3
- 2
- 60%
- UEFA Nations League
- 6
- 6
- 0
- 100%
Penalty Shoot Outs by Result
- Opposition
- Penalty Result
Full List - 103 Penalties Taken - 51 England - 52 Opposition
- Penalty Shootout: England 3-4 West Germany, 4th Jul 1990 at Stadio delle Alpi, Turin (WCF)
- 1 -
Gary Lineker
- 1 -
Andreas Brehme
- 2 -
Peter Beardsley
- 2 -
Lothar Matthäus
- 3 -
David Platt
- 3 -
Karl-Heinz Riedle
- 4 -
Stuart Pearce
(Saved by Bodo Illgner)
- 4 -
Olaf Thon
- 5 -
Chris Waddle
(Shoots over)
- Penalty Shootout: England 4-2 Spain, 22nd Jun 1996 at Wembley Stadium, London (ECF)
- 1 -
Alan Shearer
- 1 -
Fernando Hierro
(Hit the bar)
- 2 -
David Platt
- 2 -
Guillermo Amor
- 3 -
Stuart Pearce
- 3 -
Alberto Belsué
- 4 -
Paul Gascoigne
- 4 -
Miguel Ángel Nadal
(Saved by Seaman)
- Penalty Shootout: England 5-6 Germany, 26th Jun 1996 at Wembley Stadium, London (ECF)
- 1 -
Alan Shearer
- 1 -
Thomas Häßler
- 2 -
David Platt
- 2 -
Thomas Strunz
- 3 -
Stuart Pearce
- 3 -
Stefan Reuter
- 4 -
Paul Gascoigne
- 4 -
Christian Ziege
- 5 -
Teddy Sheringham
- 5 -
Stefan Kuntz
- 6 -
Gareth Southgate
(Saved by Kopke)
- 6 -
Andreas Möller
- Penalty Shootout: England 3-4 Belgium, 29th May 1998 at Stade Mohammed V, Casablanca (KHT)
- 1 -
Eric van Meir
- 1 -
Rob Lee
(Saved by van der Walle)
- 2 -
Michael Owen
- 2 -
Vital Borkelmans
- 3 -
David Beckham
- 3 -
Mbo Mpenza
- 4 -
Enzo Scifo
(Saved by Martyn)
- 4 -
Paul Merson
- 5 -
Philippe vande Walle
- 5 -
Les Ferdinand
(Saved van der Walle against the post and out.)
- Penalty Shootout: England 3-4 Argentina, 30th Jun 1998 at Stade Geoffroy-Guichard, Saint-Étienne (WCF)
- 4 -
Sergio Berti
- 1 -
Alan Shearer
- 2 -
Hernán Crespo
(Saved by Seaman)
- 2 -
Paul Ince
(Saved by Carlos Roa)
- 3 -
Juan Sebastián Verón
- 3 -
Paul Merson
- 4 -
Marcelo Gallardo
- 4 -
Michael Owen
- 5 -
Roberto Ayala
- 5 -
David Batty
(Saved by Carlos Roa)
- Penalty Shootout: England 5-6 Portugal, 24th Jun 2004 at Estádio da Luz, Lisbon (ECF)
- 1 -
David Beckham
(Shoots over)
- 1 -
Deco
- 2 -
Michael Owen
- 2 -
Simão Sabrosa
- 3 -
Frank Lampard
- 3 -
Rui Costa
(Shoots over)
- 4 -
John Terry
- 4 -
Cristiano Ronaldo
- 5 -
Owen Hargreaves
- 5 -
Maniche
- 6 -
Ashley Cole
- 6 -
Hélder Postiga
- 7 -
Darius Vassell
(Saved by Ricardo Pereira)
- 7 -
Ricardo Pereira
- Penalty Shootout: England 1-3 Portugal, 1st Jul 2006 at Arena AufSchalke, Gelsenkirchen (WCF)
- 1 -
Simo Sabrosa
- 1 -
Frank Lampard
(Saved by Ricardo Pereira)
- 1 -
Hugo Viana
(Hits the post)
- 2 -
Owen Hargreaves
- 2 -
Petit
(Shoots wide)
- 3 -
Steven Gerrard
(Saved by Ricardo Pereira)
- 3 -
Hélder Postiga
- 4 -
Jamie Carragher
(Saved by Ricardo Pereira - After re-take.)
- 4 -
Cristiano Ronaldo
- Penalty Shootout: England 2-4 Italy, 24th Jun 2012 at Olimpiyskiy, Kiev (ECF)
- 1 -
Mario Balotelli
- 1 -
Steven Gerrard
- 2 -
Riccardo Montolivo
(Shoots wide)
- 2 -
Wayne Rooney
- 3 -
Andrea Pirlo
- 3 -
Ashley Young
(Hits the bar)
- 4 -
Antonio Nocerino
- 4 -
Ashley Cole
(Saved by Buffon)
- 5 -
Alessandro Diamanti
- Penalty Shootout: England 4-3 Colombia, 3rd Jul 2018 at Otkritie Arena, Moscow (WCF)
- 1 -
Radamel Falcao
- 1 -
Harry Kane
- 2 -
Juan Cuadrado
- 2 -
Marcus Rashford
- 3 -
Luis Muriel
- 3 -
Jordan Henderson
(Saved by Ospina)
- 4 -
Mateus Uribe
(Hits the bar)
- 4 -
Kieran Trippier
- 5 -
Carlos Bacca
(Saved by Pickford)
- 5 -
Eric Dier
- Penalty Shootout: England 6-5 Switzerland, 9th Jun 2019 at Estádio D. Afonso Henriques, Guimarães (UNL)
- 1 -
Harry Maguire
- 1 -
Steven Zuber
- 2 -
Ross Barkley
- 2 -
Granit Xhaka
- 3 -
Jadon Sancho
- 3 -
Manuel Akanji
- 4 -
Raheem Sterling
- 5 -
Kevin Mbadu
- 5 -
Jordan Pickford
- 5 -
Fabian Schär
- 6 -
Eric Dier
- 6 -
Josip Drmi?
(Saved by Pickford)